I decided to make a decorated can for the pencils, much like this flower vase, using craft papers and mod podge. Made a coordinating piece for the hand sanitizer inspired by this idea.
All the preschool teachers we kept it simple and something the kids could help with. Kalla and Micah made white chocolate almond crunch (a variation of this recipe). I substituted 2-3 drops of almond OIL flavoring (if you use extract it will seize the chocolate) for the orange. Then used semi sweet chocolate drizzle on top. We bagged the candy and put in these adorable gift boxes I got at Target dollar section. We made 6 boxes for all the teachers and assistants Kalla and Micah have at their preschool. Micah also made his teachers his signature candy cane ornament. :)
Past popular ideas: